Ex Parte TANNENBAUM - Page 5



          Appeal No. 08/911,596                                                       
          Application No. 2001-2049                                                   

          reached.”  The program can also be “configured to take corrective           
          action on its own, or merely suggest what should be done.”                  
               While these cited portions of Greiner certainly appear to              
          describe capabilities closely related to what is presently                  
          claimed, the instant claims include limitations which are not               
          taught by Greiner.  For example, while Greiner may be said to               
          disclose the detection of availability of system resources                  
          operable for storing data values, such as disk space, Greiner               
          teaches nothing about that availability of the resource being               
          able to be “selectively modified in response to execution of the            
          data processing application.”  In Greiner, the availability of              
          disk space, for example, is what it is, and it may change during            
          execution of an application.  However, there is nothing in                  
          Greiner to suggest that that availability of disk space may be              
          “selectively modified.”  The operator of the instant invention              
          can prune resources consumed by the dictated document and                   
          persistent recognition data since the operator knows when he/she            
          has completed some text entry and no longer needs certain                   
          information for subsequent correction of the text.  The                     
          operator’s actions constitute the claimed “selectively modified.”           
               The examiner’s response is that the selective modification             
          in the claim “states only that the resource ‘being able’ to be              
                                         -5–                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007