Ex Parte HUBSCHER et al - Page 3


                  Appeal No. 2001-2410                                                              Page 3                     
                  Application No. 08/914,700                                                                                   

                          Claim 19 stands rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as obvious in view of                                 
                  Hossom, Leuvering, Olsen, and Akers.                                                                         
                          We reverse.                                                                                          
                                                        Background                                                             
                          The specification discloses a method for detecting analytes using                                    
                  “non-captive substrate liquid phase immunoassay techniques.”  See page 2.  The                               
                  specification states that                                                                                    
                          [o]bservations of colloidal gold or silver concentrations have been                                  
                          used in immunoassays in conjunction with solid phase diffusion                                       
                          assays.  For example, European Patent No. 207,152 discloses a                                        
                          solid phase diffusion assay utilizing a porous sheet having ligands                                  
                          or receptors prebound to the sheet prior to the application of an                                    
                          analyte and a colloidal gold or silver labeled ligand or receptor.                                   
                  Id.  This method, however, has the drawback that the “ligand or antiligand coated                            
                  porous films must be specifically tailored for a particular analyte and . . . may be                         
                  ineffective if the affinity of the substrate bound antiligand for the labeled analyte                        
                  is low.”  Id.                                                                                                
                          The specification also discusses a sandwich immunoassay method that                                  
                  involves “premixing a biological specimen with:  (1) a colloidal gold labeled ligand                         
                  or antiligand and (2) solid phase captive particles coated with a ligand or                                  
                  antiligand and applying the subsequent mixture onto the surface of a porous                                  
                  film.”  Id.  This method also has a drawback, in that the solid phase captive                                
                  particles (e.g., latex particles) “may distort the visual detection measurements                             
                  because uncoupled captive particles may block the pores of the substrate and                                 
                  prevent rapid passage of uncoupled colloidal gold.”  Id., pages 2-3.                                         






Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007