Ex Parte APPELMAN - Page 11




            Appeal No. 2002-0366                                                  Page 11              
            Application No. 08/803,692                                                                 


            they do not want to be disturbed, this is indicated by the icon                            
            (figure 2).  To contact another worker, the current worker                                 
            selects one or more of his icons 14, 17 and presses the contact                            
            button (col. 8, lines 3-5).  Turning to Tang'173, we find that                             
            Tang'173 discloses various modes of awareness about other                                  
            workers.  The mode of awareness is specified by each worker                                
            independently, and controls both ends of the encounter, i.e., how                          
            the encounter mechanism appears to the current worker, and how                             
            the current worker appears to the encounter window 20 of the                               
            other workers.  The open mode is used by workers who are                                   
            receptive to interacting with other workers who are task                                   
            proximate (col. 6, line 66 through col. 7, line 17).  From the                             
            disclosure of Tang'173 we find that by selecting the open mode,                            
            the worker grants permission to have himself added to the                                  
            encounter window of other subscribers.  If he chooses the closed                           
            mode, no representation of him is provided to the other workers.                           
            Thus, by choosing the open mode, the worker grants permission to                           
            have other logged-on workers add him to the other workers’                                 
            encounter window.  In addition, we find from Tang'365 that a co-                           
            worker is selected by selecting his icon and pressing the contact                          
            button.  Thus, we find that the combined teachings of Tang'365                             
            and Tang'173 teach the steps set forth in the method of claim 27,                          







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007