Ex Parte HO et al - Page 3


          Appeal No. 2002-0404                                                          
          Application No. 08/859,143                                                    

               acrylic acid-containing feedstock with a butanol-                        
               containing feedstock to produce a butyl acrylate-                        
               containing product stream comprising butyl acrylate,                     
               dibutyl ether, butyl acetate, heavies and butanol;                       
                    b.  introducing said product stream into a                          
               splitter distillation column to provide an overhead                      
               fraction comprising dibutyl ether, butyl acetate,                        
               butyl acrylate and butanol and a bottoms fraction                        
               comprising butyl acrylate and heavies;                                   
                    c.  withdrawing from the splitter distillation                      
               column the bottoms fraction;                                             
                    d.  separating heavies from said bottom fraction                    
               by introducing the bottoms fraction into a butyl                         
               acrylate distillation column to provide an overhead                      
               product containing butyl acrylate and a bottom product                   
               containing heavies;                                                      
                    e.  withdrawing from the splitter distillation                      
               column the overhead fraction; and                                        
                    f.  introducing the overhead fraction into a                        
               butanol recovery distillation column to provide an                       
               overhead stream comprising dibutyl ether and butyl                       
               acetate and a bottoms stream comprising butanol;                         
                    g.  withdrawing from the butanol recovery                           
               distillation column the bottoms stream; and                              
                    h.  supplying at least a portion of the bottom                      
               stream to said at least one reaction zone.                               
                    11.  At least ten thousand pounds (avoir) of a                      
               butyl acrylate product comprising at least 99.8wt%                       
               butyl acrylate and containing not more than about 200                    
               ppm butyl ether and not more than about 200 ppm butyl                    
               acetate.                                                                 
               The examiner relies on the following prior art references                
          as evidence of unpatentability:                                               
          Erpenbach et al.              4,280,010            Jul. 21, 1981             
               (Erpenbach)                                                              
          Dougherty et al.              4,814,493            Mar. 21, 1989             
               (Dougherty)                                                              
          Aldrich: Catalog Handbook of Fine Chemicals 256 (Date                         
          Uncertain)(Aldrich).                                                          

                                           3                                            



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007