Ex Parte KIM et al - Page 4




          Appeal No. 2002-0857                                                         
          Application No. 09219,876                                                    


          predetermined amount of time, a screen saver image is displayed              
          on the computer screen.  This is merely a recitation of the                  
          operation of a conventional screen saver.                                    
               While the screen saver image is displayed and a visiting                
          party hits the “enter” key, a note-taker user interface is                   
          displayed [Franklin, column 8, lines 35-40].  This note-taker                
          user interface is a “first input window.”  Thus, Franklin                    
          discloses “when the computer screen displays said screen saver               
          image and when input is detected from an input device, displaying            
          a first input window on the computer screen,” as claimed.                    
               However, if such is the interpretation, then Franklin would             
          not disclose “when said first input window is displayed, if a                
          first particular input is detected, displaying a message input               
          window, then storing message data input while the message input              
          window is displayed, then displaying said screen saver image”                
          because the message input window of Franklin, ostensibly client              
          area 116, is already part of note-taker user interface 110 and               
          would not be displayed “when said first input window is                      
          displayed, if a first particular input is detected...”                       
               It is the examiner’s view that Franklin’s password dialog               
          window is the “first input window.”  This is a reasonable                    
          interpretation since a user or a visitor moving a mouse or                   

                                         -4–                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007