Ex Parte WAGNER et al - Page 5



          Appeal No. 2002-1573                                                        
          Application No. 09/113,446                                                  

          with the electronics enclosure portion having an aperture                   
          entirely surrounded by a body perimeter portion.                            

               The recitation of a "one-piece" hollow body portion is                 
          clearly understood when read in light of the underlying                     
          specification (page 4, lines 10 through 12) which expressly                 
          recites the following.                                                      
                    Body portion 12 is made as a single part                          
                    rather than as two joined halves.  This                           
                    eliminates the need for bonding or otherwise                      
                    joining two halves and also eliminates the                        
                    presence of an unattractive seam line.                            

               Based upon the above, the claim recitation of a "one-piece"            
          hollow body portion denotes a hollow body portion fabricated from           
          a single part and not from halves (parts) joined together.                  

               The patent to Schmidt teaches a housing for a portable bar             
          code symbol reading device (a portable handheld electronic                  
          reader/scanner).  The patentee discloses (column 13, lines 53               
          through 67) that the hand-supportable housing is a "five-piece              
          split housing," with a first housing portion 9C and a second                
          housing half 9D being provided, as seen in Figs. 3A.  The showing           
          in the patent, e.g., Fig. 1E, makes it visually apparent that the           
                                          5                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007