Ex Parte CHORNENKY et al - Page 7


          Appeal No. 2002-2152                                                       
          Application No. 08/701,764                                                 

          in the claimed invention.  In particular, Forde describes an x-            
          ray device for diagnosing and treating lesions of a pathological           
          nature occurring with various body cavities or orifices of the             
          human body.  (Page 1, lines 44-54.)  Although Forde discloses a            
          “thin-walled molybdenum cup 21” (element 21, Figure 8), there is           
          no teaching in this reference of a “conductive coating on the              
          external surface of the insulator, wherein...the conductive                
          coating is electrically connected to the cathode,” as required             
          by the appealed claims.                                                    
               Tang’s teachings are equally ineffective to support the               
          examiner’s position.  Tang describes an x-ray head including an            
          evacuated chamber in which an anode and a cathode are disposed             
          and electrical connections from the anode to the cathode extend            
          through the wall of the evacuated chamber.  (Column 2, lines               
          2-7.)  Tang teaches: “The anode 12 may be a metal foil separate            
          from the wall 10 or may be a metal film deposited on a part of             
          the inside surface of the wall 10 by vacuum evaporation or                 
          another known technique.”  (Column 4, lines 24-27.)  Like Forde,           
          however, Tang lacks any teaching with respect to a “conductive             
          coating on the external surface of the insulator, wherein...the            
          conductive coating is electrically connected to the cathode,” as           
          required by the appealed claims.                                           



                                          7                                          



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007