Ex Parte ASTA - Page 11




              Appeal No. 2003-0017                                                               Page 11                
              Application No. 09/326,996                                                                                


              common to both tubes, the tubes being substantially coextensive and having upper and                      
              lower ends.  The outer tube has two legs releasably attached thereto adjacent its lower                   
              end and adapted to hold said apparatus in a general vertical free-standing position                       
              when resting on a horizontal surface.  The outer tube at its bottom end includes an                       
              expandable contractable means to expand sufficiently to encircle a golf ball and                          
              then contract sufficiently to grip the golf ball and hold it against the bottom end of the                
              inner tube when the bottom end of the inner tube is retracted to the bottom end                           
              of the outer tube and then to expand again and release the golf ball when the bottom                      
              end of the inner tube is protracted outwardly from the bottom end of the outer                            
              tube.                                                                                                     


                     As shown in Figure 1, two legs 24 made of heavy wire are provided which                            
              together with lower end 23 of inner tube 21 (with golf ball 26 gripped by fingers 25) form                
              a tripod to allow the apparatus to stand in generally vertical position, tipped to an angle               
              of about 10°-20° from the vertical.  The legs 24 are locked securely at the desired angle                 
              which provides stability for the apparatus.  Luther teaches (column 4, line 67, to column                 
              3, line 2) that "[i]t is, of course, entirely within the scope of this invention to employ other          
              types of legs, whether permanently attached or detachably connected."                                     











Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007