Ex Parte Franet - Page 5




               Appeal No. 2003-0679                                                                           Page 5                   
               Application No. 09/730,163                                                                                              


               denied, 465 U.S. 1026 (1984), it is only necessary for the claims to "'read on' something                               
               disclosed in the reference, i.e., all limitations of the claim are found in the reference, or                           
               'fully met' by it."                                                                                                     


                       Freudendahl discloses a combination of mowers for grass crops.  As shown in                                     
               Figure 4, the combination of mowers comprises a mower unit 2' for front mounting on a                                   
               tractor 1' and two mower units 33, 34 for rear mounting on the tractor 1' arranged on                                   
               either side of the tractor 1'.  The rear mounted mower units 33, 34 project obliquely                                   
               rearwards and have adjusting means over discharge openings 48, 49 for placing the                                       
               discharged swath 24 immediately adjacent the swath 6 discharged by the front mounted                                    
               mower unit 2' for combining/bunching three swaths in one operation.  The rear mounted                                   
               mower units 33, 34 can be swung about pivot joints 41, 42 by means of hydraulic                                         
               activators 43, 44 from the illustrated operating position to a substantially vertical                                   
               conveyance position.  The adjusting means over discharge openings 48, 49 is shown in                                    
               Figures 2 and 3 as being a pivotable flap 22 adjustable by means of a hydraulic                                         
               activator 23.                                                                                                           


                       Freudendahl does not anticipate independent claim 1.  In that regard,                                           
               Freudendahl's swath formers (i.e., the discharge openings 48, 49 with adjustable flaps)                                 
               are mounted to the mowing units 33, 34 not to the mobile central frame on which the                                     








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007