Ex Parte Lien - Page 7




               Appeal No. 2004-0088                                                                      Page 7                  
               Application No. 09/821,663                                                                                        


               within the enclosure by the closing element engaging with the restraining holder without                          
               providing a gripping contact that would make removal of the pill difficult.                                       


                      With this understanding, we turn to Mumford to ascertain if Mumford's container                            
               includes a top section having a closing element that engages with the restraining holder                          
               within the bottom section to prevent the pill from moving without restraint within the                            
               enclosure.  Figures 1-6 of Mumford illustrate a selectively openable, telescopically                              
               closeable tablet container 10.  The container includes a lid 12 and a base 14 adapted to                          
               be brought into telescopic closed relationship.  Lid 12 includes a panel 16 and a                                 
               peripheral skirt which includes opposed sidewalls 18, front wall 20, and a rear wall 22.                          
               Depending downwardly from the internal surface of panel 16 is an annular wall 52.                                 
               Base 14 includes a panel 30, opposed sidewalls 24, a front wall 26 and a rear wall 28                             
               which walls proceed upwardly from panel 30.  Also proceeding upwardly, and disposed                               
               internally of the container 10, is an annular wall 54 integrally formed on panel 30.  Wall                        
               52 and wall 54 are so proportioned that when lid 12 is brought into telescopic relation                           
               about base 14 they inter-engage to define a sealed, internally disposed tablet chamber                            
               53.  Container 10 is formed as a single piece by providing a generally U-shaped hinge                             
               34 which connects rear wall 22 of lid 12 and rear wall 28 of base 14.  As shown in                                
               Figures 1 and 3 of Mumford, the tablets are free to move within the tablet chamber 53.                            









Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007