Ex Parte KELLEY et al - Page 5




          Appeal No. 2002-0665                                                        
          Application 08/977,519                                                      


          constructing a web page of the accessed icon and link programs              
          and data files such that the HTML tag is displayed on the web               
          page and executable by the web browser to execute said program on           
          the operating system are met by the teachings and suggestions at            
          column 17, lines 25-30 and column 18, line 49 through column 20,            
          line 7 as expressed at various portions of the answer.  With this           
          conclusion we disagree.                                                     
               Our study of the following portions of Slivka leads us to              
          conclude that the noted features emphasized earlier in this                 
          opinion are not taught or suggested by Slivka: the Abstract; the            
          Summary of the Invention at column 3, line 31 through column 4,             
          line 25; column 6, lines 20-40 discussing HTML tags; column 11 in           
          its entirety and its corresponding discussion of Figure 2's shell           
          50, pre-processor 60, desktop interface control 64, shell                   
          explorer 72, and hypertext viewer 70 as they relate to the                  
          display and formulation of the hypertext page 56 and the                    
          hypertext view 54 at the bottom of Figure 2; for emphasis, we               
          make reference to column 11, lines 51-65 and include in this                
          listing of pertinent portions of Slivka the two earlier noted               
          portions relied upon by the examiner.                                       




                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007