Ex Parte SUTTERLIN et al - Page 14



          Appeal No. 2002-1318                                                        
          Application No. 08/693,662                                                  

          appellants specification discloses (page 6), with respect to                
          figure 1, that:                                                             
          If node N1 has a message for node N5, the message must be                   
          transmitted through the source 13.  The source 13 typically                 
          involves a transformer or the like which does not provide an                
          effective transmission path for a data signal having a frequency            
          much higher than the power frequency.  For instance, where each             
          node includes a transceiver such as manufactured by Echelon                 
          Corporation, part no. PLT-20/21, signals are transmitted between            
          the nodes at a frequency (when compared to 60Hz) of 131.5789kHz.            
          This relatively high frequency is in some instances not                     
          effectively transmitted from line 14 to lines 15 or 16 through a            
          transformer.                                                                
               We find from this disclosure of appellants that it was known           
          to transmit signals between the nodes of power lines at a high              
          frequency, e.g., 131.5789kHz (i.e. 132kHz).  The specification              
          additionally discloses (id.) with respect to figure 2 that "these           
          lines are not connected in a way that permits effective                     
          distribution of a high frequency (e.g., 132kHz) communications              
          signal," and that (page 7) “[t]he RF receivers 24 and 25 may be             
          ordinary radio frequency receivers tuned to receive signals of              
          the frequency of the communication signal in the network (e.g.,             
          132kHz).”                                                                   
               From the disclosure that the transmitted signal is at 132kHz           
          and that the signals picked up by RF receivers 24 and 25 is                 
          132kHz, we find that the signals transmitted between the nodes of           

                                         14                                           




Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007