Ex Parte FLORENCIO - Page 5




                    Appeal No. 2002-1453                                                                                                                                  
                    Application No. 09/160,790                                                                                                                            


                    an encoding mode of said DCT coefficient block.  Appellant also                                                                                       
                    shows that independent claims 1 and 20 positively recite this                                                                                         
                    limitation.  See pages 8 and 9 of Appellant's brief.  Appellant                                                                                       
                    points out that Yonemitsu merely provides an additional                                                                                               
                    processing function at a decoder for correcting prediction errors                                                                                     
                    produced.  The basis functions used within the Yonemitsu process                                                                                      
                    are standard basis functions.  Appellant argues that there is no                                                                                      
                    disclosure or suggestion within Yonemitsu of any adaptation of                                                                                        
                    basis functions, much less the claimed adaptation of basis                                                                                            
                    functions in response to an encoding mode of a DCT coefficient                                                                                        
                    block.  See pages 10-12 of Appellant's brief.                                                                                                         
                              Upon our review of Yonemitsu, we find that Yonemitsu does                                                                                   
                    teach an IDCT circuit 113.  Also, we find that Yonemitsu teaches                                                                                      
                    that the IDCT circuit 113 performs an inverse transform to                                                                                            
                    produce 4x4 pixel data groups.  See column 17, line 61 through                                                                                        
                    column 18, line 8.  However, we fail to find that Yonemitsu                                                                                           
                    performs IDCT using modified basis functions versus the standard                                                                                      
                    basis functions in response to an encoding mode such as the frame                                                                                     
                    mode.  Therefore, we fail to find that Yonemitsu teaches                                                                                              
                    transforming, according to an inverse discrete cosine transform                                                                                       
                    (IDCT), said resized DCT coefficient block to produce said pixel                                                                                      
                    block having said second resolution, said step of transforming                                                                                        

                                                                                    55                                                                                    





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007