Ex Parte WARD et al - Page 6




                 Appeal No. 2003-1482                                                                                   
                 Application No.  09/156,816                                                                            

                 of counting.   The claims require counting of a pixel clock or valid pixels, which is                  
                 not met by counting edges of the horizontal synchronizing signal to determine its                      
                 frequency as is taught by Kesatoshi (see column 5, lines 44-45).  While we do                          
                 find that Reddy teaches, in column 8, lines 41-42, that “the number of pixels in                       
                 each horizontal line can be determined to determine the format of the video                            
                 signal” and, in column 8, lines 27-29, “[t]he number of horizontal lines per image                     
                 is detected by counting a number of HSYNC pulses which occur between                                   
                 adjacent VSYNC pulses.”  Reddy teaches that these two methods are                                      
                 alternatives.  Further, we consider the examiner’s statement that column 9, lines                      
                 13-41 of Reddy teach determining the active horizontal and active vertical                             
                 resolution to be misplaced as we find that the cited section of Reddy teaches                          
                 capturing the video signal after the video format has been determined.  Thus, we                       
                 do not find that Reddy teaches that both the counting of pixels in the horizontal                      
                 line and a counting of the vertical resolution are performed to determine the                          
                 active resolution.                                                                                     













                                                           6                                                            



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007