Ex Parte BAKER et al - Page 6




               Appeal No. 2003-1841                                                                          Page 6                   
               Application No. 09/272,956                                                                                             


               1200-b, 1200-c and 1200-d for relaying the communication among the portable                                            
               communication devices; switching devices 1300-a and 1300-b for switching connections                                   
               among the radio base stations; and a transmission device 1400 for connecting between                                   
               the switching devices. . . ."  Col. 23, ll. 32-41.  We agree with the examiner that the                                
               reference "teach[es] a state machine (1100a, 1100b (see figures 2, 24), operating from                                 
               one state to another state (see figures 4A-4G, 9)) . . . so as to control assignment of the                            
               sets of labels (see figures 4A-4G) to soft-labeled keys (1A-1D) (see figure 2) in                                      
               response to user input without requiring further information from the switch. . . ."                                   
               (Examiner's Answer at 4.)  More specifically, Suzuki explains that each state machine                                  
               includes "an initial communication waiting state," col. 5, ll. 25-26; "a 'memory call' state,"                         
               id. at ll. 27; and "a speaking state (line connected state). . . ."  Id. at ll. 28-29.                                 


                       Furthermore, Figures 4A-4C of Suzuki show that the labels for the SLKs of each                                 
               device are controlled according to the state machines.  "In th[e] initial communication                                
               waiting state of FIG. 4A, the input key 1A is [labeled] as an input key for switching the                              
               operation state into a 'memory call' mode, the input key 1C is [labeled] as an input key                               
               for switching the operation state into an 'auxiliary function' mode, and the input key 1D                              
               is [labeled] as an input key for switching the operation state into a 're-dial' mode.                                  











Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007