Ex Parte CLAPPER - Page 6



          Appeal No. 2004-0324                                                        
          Application 09/387,350                                                      

          on that page, as an activation of predefined textual information            
          stored in the database to be automatically inserted into a text             
          entry field as recited broadly in independent claim 17 on appeal            
          is misplaced since we do not agree with the examiner's views that           
          the entire subject matter of the claims on appeal is met.                   
          Namely, there appears to be no ability taught in Dell for the               
          user to enter any text information into the fields shown in the             
          drop down menu box relied upon by the examiner in Dell.  Thus,              
          without an ability of the user to enter information into the text           
          entry field, since there is no true text entry field that allows            
          the user to enter text, the feature at the end of independent               
          claim 17 cannot be met of the selectability of the given state              
          "prior to entry by the user of text into said text entry field."            
          Corresponding features recited in independent claim 1 on appeal             
          upon the selection of a text entry field, plus selection of the             
          one of the entries of the options shown in the displayed text               
          options, the reference to Dell does not allow any operations to             
          occur "prior to the user inputting text into said text entry                
          field."  The identical feature of independent claim 1 is also               
          recited in independent claim 9 on appeal.                                   



                                          6                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007