Ex Parte HEMMINGER - Page 15



          Appeal No. 2004-0820                                                        
          Application No. 09/317,312                                Page 15           

          the other computers.  However, from the disclosure of Glaser                
          (col. 4, lines 44-55) that:                                                 
               Thus, those skilled in the art will appreciate                         
               that the conference participants can use keyboards                     
               of thier respective workstations and their display                     
               mouses and the like to enter information in the                        
               common whiteboard area 60 and have the informmation                    
          displayed in the whiteboard area of all the conference                      
          participants.  A vertical scroll bar 62 is provided                         
               at the right edge of the working area and a horizontal                 
               scroll bar 64 is provided along the bottom edge of the                 
               work area.  As will be familiar to those skilled in the                
               art, the scroll bars are used to control positioning                   
               of the objects displayed in the work area                              
          we find that because the scroll bars are used to control                    
          positioning of the objects in the work area, that upon using the            
          scroll bars to scroll down a page shown in the whiteboard area,             
          that the portion scrolled to will be displayed in the whiteboard            
          area.  However, this does not mean that the display will be                 
          occuring subsequent to termination of the scrolling.  As Glaser             
          is silent as how this takes place and when the display is shown             
          on the computers of the other participants, we find that Glaser             
          does not disclose that upon detection of the termination of                 
          scrolling, ascertaining which part of the document is being                 
          displayed by the computer, and after said ascertainment,                    
          transmitting to the other computers data which enables them to              
          display said part of the document.                                          






Page:  Previous  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007