Ex Parte Wollaston et al - Page 10




          Appeal No. 2004-1150                                                        
          Application No. 09/924,490                                                  


          doing, the first sheet A is spirally wrapped upon itself so that            
          adjacent turns adjoin and preferably overlap, and a second sheet B          
          is spirally wrapped upon itself so that adjacent turns adjoin and           
          preferably overlap (column 3, lines 8-12).  Sheet B is preferably           
          corrugated across its width and length to add stiffness to the              
          structure (column 3, lines 44-48).  The adjoining or overlapping            
          edges of sheet A and B are permanently joined, as are the sheet             
          themselves to each other, to form an integral structure (column 4,          
          line 73, to column 5, line 3).  This is preferably done by welding          
          in a continuous operation, although spot welding or other securing          
          means such as rivets or screw fasteners may be used (column 5,              
          lines 3-27).                                                                
               Ellzey differs from the invention claimed in claims 1, 13 and          
          37 in that it does not disclose that the sheets A and B are joined          
          together by using friction stir welding.                                    
               Thomas is directed to a friction stir butt welding technique           
          (abstract).  The friction stir welding technique of Thomas may be           
          used to join metal and alloys (column 2, line 23), including                
          aluminum alloys (column 7, line 51).  Friction stir welding may be          
          applied to a variety of joint configurations, including sheets              
          having abutting faces (Figure 1) and the arrangement shown in               
          Figure 10A where the weld 12 is used to join overlapping sheets.            

                                         10                                           





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007