Ex Parte MEDINA et al - Page 7




              Appeal No. 2004-1316                                                                  Page 7                
              Application No. 09/241,276                                                                                  


              use."  Col. 2, ll. 22-25.  "Employing VDE creation software . . . and VDE templates,                        
              users may create VDE objects 300 by, for example, partitioning the objects, placing                         
              'meta data' (e.g., author's name, creation date, etc.) into them, and assigning rights                      
              associated with them and/or object content to, for example, a publisher and/or content                      
              creator."  Col. 257, ll. 23-29.  "When an object creator runs through this process,                         
              she [sic] normally will go through a content specification procedure which will request                     
              required data.  The content specification process, when satisfied, may proceed by, for                      
              example, inserting data into a template and encapsulating the content."  Id. at ll. 29-34.                  


                     The examiner does not allege, let alone show, that the reference stores metadata                     
              in a database for subsequent retrieval and insertion into a metadata template.  To the                      
              contrary, he explains that in "Ginter . . . an operator is the entity that manually acquires                
              the information that is inserted into the template."  (Examiner's Answer at 17.)  Lacking                   
              a database for storing metadata, the reference does not include any table for mapping                       
              data fields of its VDE template to locations in such as database as admitted by the                         
              examiner.  (Id. at 9.)                                                                                      















Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007