Ex Parte Dunshee et al - Page 4



          Appeal No. 2004-1372                                                        
          Application No. 09/577,551                                                  

          column 1, lines 7-10 and column 3, line 34 to column 4, line 1,             
          together with Figure 1.  The indicia and markings are placed on the         
          flexible bandages by using any known printing techniques involving          
          inks.  See column 3, lines 20-29, together with Figures 1-9.                
               The appellants do not argue that these flexible bandages are           
          not elastomeric bandages.  Rather, the appellants argue that there          
          is no motivation or suggestion to employ the claimed ink                    
          composition to prepare the indicia or markings in Hessel’s flexible         
          bandages.  We do not agree.                                                 
               The examiner has correctly found that both Miyamoto and Davey          
          teach various advantages of using the claimed printing ink                  
          composition on plastic substrates or films.  Miyamoto, for example,         
          teaches water-based printing inks containing particles of a                 
          urethane polymer and a pigment for various flexible plastic films,          
          inclusive of the flexible elastomeric backings used in Hessel’s             
          bandages.  See page 2, lines 1-7, page 7, lines 9-20 and 45-48.             
          These inks, according to Miyamoto, exhibit strong adhesion and peel         
          strength to various kinds of plastic films and are good for                 
          occupational safety and food hygiene. See pages 2 and 21.  Davey            
          also teaches using a primer containing polyurethane resin and a             
          pigment to improve adherence of an ink to a polymeric film and              

                                          4                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007