Ex Parte Safian - Page 2



          Appeal No. 2005-0084                                                        
          Application No. 09/835,726                                                  

                    said inner layer being a relatively thin flexible                 
               plastic layer that extends around an inner surface of                  
               said outer layer and is unadhered to said outer layer,                 
                    said inner flexible layer being of uniform                        
               thickness throughout, having a portion that overlies                   
               said vent opening, and having a portion engaging the                   
               inner surface of said finish and a radially extending                  
               flange portion overlying said axial end of said finish.                
               The examiner relies upon the following references as                   
          evidence of obviousness:                                                    
          Avery                         4,982,872           Jan. 08, 1991             
          Ellion et al. (Ellion)        5,497,911           Mar. 12, 1996             
          Kobayashi et al. (Kobayashi) 5,513,761            May  07, 1996             
          Thomas                        EP 0 182 094        May  02, 1986             
          Takakusagi et al. (JP ‘069)   JP 6-345,069        Dec. 20, 1994             
          Okada et al. (JP ‘561)        JP 8-183,561        Jul. 16, 1996             
               Appellant’s claimed invention is directed to a multilayer              
          container that is formed by coextruding and blow molding inner              
          and outer layers of plastic material.  The outer layer has a base           
          portion comprising an atmospheric vent opening.  The vent opening           
          is formed by the removal of material from the base after the blow           
          molding operation.  Appellant submits that “[t]he appealed claims           
          of the present application are directed specifically to the                 
          atmospheric vent opening 42" (page 3 of principal brief, third              
          paragraph).                                                                 

                                          2                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007