Ex Parte EGGLESTON et al - Page 11



          Appeal No. 2003-2074                                                        
          Application No. 09/095,325                                                  

          client is forwarded to the mobile client via the host system                
          independent of any proactive step by the user of the mobile                 
          client.  Appellants point out that the forwarding process begins            
          with query manager 231 of the communication server 220 and not              
          the mobile client 201.  Therefore, argue appellants, the newly              
          received mail is “continuously forwarded” (i.e., pushed not                 
          pulled) from the host system to the mobile client (see page 5 of            
          the reply brief).                                                           
               We agree with appellants.  The examiner’s explanation                  
          appears to interpret the “continuously forwarding” feature as a             
          never ending delivery of mail to the mobile client from the                 
          server.  In fact, the description at page 12 of the                         
          specification, along with a reference to Figure 3, makes it clear           
          to us, that “continuously forwarding” merely describes how the              
          host server looks for email for the mobile client and, at such              
          times as such email is found, the host server delivers, or                  
          “forwards” such mail to the mobile client.  Hence, the host                 
          server is “continuously forwarding” such email to the mobile                
          client, rather than having to wait for the mobile client to                 
          request the forwarding of such email.  Viewed in this                       
          interpretive manner, it is clear that the instant specification             

                                        -11-                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007