Ex Parte Wirth et al - Page 18




                Appeal No. 2005-0948                                                                          Page 18                   
                Application No. 09/922,938                                                                                              



                Claim 15                                                                                                                
                        We will not sustain the rejection of claim 15 under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as being                                    
                unpatentable over Hardy in view of McCormack, Gray and Lebermann.                                                       


                        Claim 15 reads as follows:                                                                                      
                                A Iathe assembly comprising:                                                                            
                                a base unit having first and second longitudinal ends,                                                  
                                a headstock assembly provided adjacent said first Iongitudinal end of said                              
                        base unit, said headstock assembly including a spindle housing having a spindle                                 
                        shaft extending therethrough,                                                                                   
                                a first Iathe bed assembly provided on said base unit and including a                                   
                        bedway extending Iongitudinally in a direction parallel to said longitudinal axis of                            
                        said spindle for slidably receiving at Ieast one of a tool rest and a tailstock;                                
                                a second lathe bed assembly detachably coupled to at Ieast one of said first                            
                        and second Iongitudinal ends of said base unit, said second bed assembly                                        
                        including a second bedway for selectively receiving at least one of a tailstock and                             
                        a tool rest assembly; and                                                                                       
                                an indexing assembly for angularly positioning and holding said spindle                                 
                        shaft with respect to said spindle housing at any one of a plurality of intervals, said                         
                        indexing assembly including an indexing component fixedly secured to said                                       
                        spindle shaft and an indexing pin mounted to said spindle housing of said                                       
                        headstock assembly, and spring urged toward engagement with said indexing                                       
                        component.                                                                                                      


                        The pertinent teachings of McCormack and Gray have been set forth above.                                        


                        Hardy's invention as noted above relates to indexing lathes.  The lathe includes a                              
                headstock bracket 16 mounted on the bed 10 at the end thereof opposite the tailstock 12                                 








Page:  Previous  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007