Ex Parte Croce et al - Page 5


          Appeal No. 2006-0255                                                           
          Application No. 09/839,596                                                     

          specific arrangement of conductive regions within a semiconductor              
          substrate.  In view of the discussion above, we look to see if                 
          the device recited in claim 5 exists in the Huang device.  The                 
          regions of conductivity as recited in claim 5 exist in Huang as                
          pointed out by the examiner.  In our view, the question is                     
          whether the regions identified by the examiner can properly be                 
          called a “drain region,” a “body region” and a “source region” as              
          recited in claim 5.  The examiner identifies source region 11 of               
          Huang as the claimed source region, and region 11 is described as              
          a source region in Huang [column 7, lines 6-7].  The claimed body              
          region connotes no particular function, and region 9 of Huang can              
          be a body region as identified by the examiner.  The examiner                  
          identifies region 2 of Huang as the drain region.  This region 2               
          is separated from the source region 11 by the body region 9 and                
          the buffer region 13 as identified by the examiner.  Huang                     
          discloses that the buffer region 13 prevents punch-through                     
          between region 9 and region 2 [column 7, lines 14-16].  The fact               
          that buffer region 13 of Huang prevents punch-through suggests                 
          that region 2 acts as a drain with respect to source 11 in                     
          Huang’s device.  Therefore, region 2 of Huang is a drain region                
          as asserted by the examiner.  Thus, the regions as recited in                  
          claim 5 exist in Huang in the manner recited in claim 5.                       


                                           5                                             




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007