Ex Parte Copp - Page 2



          Appeal No. 2006-1062                                                        
          Application No. 10/246,994                                                  

               plate having a straight longitudinal distal edge, a working            
               surface against which paint is collected when said distal              
               edge is held against a surface being painted and a non-                
               working surface in partial contact with the masked surface             
               during operation; and                                                  
                    a plurality of overlying and paint impervious cover               
               elements, in a detachably stacked relationship, each said              
               element having an upper surface and a lower surface, each              
               said lower surface including a pressure sensitive adhesive             
               coating upon at least a portion thereof, said pressure                 
               sensitive adhesive on at least one element adhesively                  
               connected to said paint shield, said elements arranged in              
               overlying and juxtaposed relationship thereby providing a              
               plurality of renewable and multi-use protective upper                  
               surface of said cover elements, said cover elements in                 
               contiguous contact with the paint shield for providing                 
               substantially complete protective cover to said paint                  
               shield.                                                                
               The examiner relies upon the following references as                   
          evidence of obviousness:                                                    
          De Guzman                     4,917,975             Apr. 17, 1990           
          Frazier                       4,937,910             Jul.  3, 1990           
          Thompson                      4,962,722             Oct. 16, 1990           
          Holt                          5,201,954             Apr. 13, 1993           
          Su                            5,286,546             Feb. 15, 1994           
          Renetta                       6,315,831             Nov. 13, 2001           
               Appellant’s claimed invention is directed to a hand held               
          paint shield for protecting a surface to be masked during                   
          painting.  The assembly comprises a generally flat, elongated               
          plate connected to a handle.  The working surface of the paint              
          shield collects the paint that is masked and is protected by a              
          plurality of overlying, paint impervious cover elements.  A                 

                                          2                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007