Ex Parte Chang et al - Page 2



            Appeal No. 2006-1225                                                                            
            Application No. 10/244,825                                                                      

            bus identification to a storage device included in the storage                                  
            system and creating a zone including a switch and the storage                                   
            device included in the storage system.  According to Appellants,                                
            in such a system data only passes to the storage device from the                                
            switch, and access to the storage device is restricted to that                                  
            from a server included in the storage system (specification, page                               
            1).  An understanding of the invention can be derived from a                                    
            reading of exemplary independent claim 1, which is reproduced as                                
            follows:                                                                                        
                   1.    A method for constraining access to a storage system                               
            comprises:                                                                                      
                   assigning a permanent bus identification to a storage device                             
            included in the storage system;                                                                 
                   grouping a switch and the storage device included in the                                 
            storage system such that data only passes to the storage device                                 
            from the switch; and                                                                            
                   restricting access to the storage device from a server                                   
            included in the storage system.                                                                 
                   The Examiner relies on the following reference:                                          
            Ogata                           JP 02001-306412A                Nov. 2, 20013                   
                   Claims 1-24 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 102(a) as being                             
            anticipated by Ogata.                                                                           


                   3  An English translation of the reference was previously provided by                    
            the Examiner, to which all the references in this opinion are made.                             
                                                     2                                                      




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007