Appeal No. 2006-1643 Παγε 18
Application No. 09/845,589
lines 38-52 of Monn for a teaching of providing other visual
images after fixing the visual image.
At the outset, we make reference to our findings, supra,
with respect to the teachings and suggestions of FJCP and Monn.
From the disclosure of Monn (col. 4, lines 38-42) that 30 seconds
after affixing the photocopy that has been pasted to the box,
another photocopy can be pasted on the box, to assemble a collage
of overlapping photocopies, we agree with the examiner that the
combined teachings of FJCP and Monn would have suggested
providing other images to the scrapbook page before or after
affixing the visual image to the scrapbook page, as recited in
claim 14. The rejection of claim 14 is sustained.
We turn next to claim 15. Appellants (brief, page 12)
incorporate by reference the previously argued reasons for
reversal of the rejection of claim 1. Appellants additionally
assert (id.) that
Claim 15 also calls for the method to include
“following instructions for producing a series of
digital images of a single same image where each of the
digital images of the single same image have different
characteristics”. As discussed above, FJCP provides no
instructions regarding producing images or how to use
Page: Previous 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 Next
Last modified: November 3, 2007