Ex Parte Boatwright et al - Page 2

         Appeal Number: 2006-1706                                                 
         Application Number: 10/216,111                                           

              8.  A one-piece, polymer overcap for a tubular composite            
         container having at least one flexible end closure attached              
         to an end thereof and being of a type in which products can be           
         vacuum packaged, the one-piece, polymer overcap comprising:              
         a base portion having inner and outer surfaces and                       
         defining an outer perimeter;                                             
         a skirt extending circumferentially about said outer                     
         perimeter of said base portion; and                                      
         a bias member extending away from said inner surface of                  
         said base portion, said bias member being adapted for biasing            
         the at least one flexible end closure towards the products               
         before a vacuum is applied.                                              

                                  THE REFERENCE                                   
         Beery                       1,654,914               Jan. 3, 1928         
                                  THE REJECTION                                   
              Claims 8-14, 23 and 24 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103         
         as being unpatentable over Beery.                                        
                                     OPINION                                      
              We affirm the aforementioned rejection.                             
              The appellants state that the claims stand or fall together         
         (brief, page 4).  We therefore limit our discussion to one               
         claim, i.e., claim 8.  See 37 CFR 41.37(c)(1)(vii)(2004).                
              Beery discloses a jar having a screw cap (27) that forces a         
         presser member (1) downwardly to push solid food products below          
         fluid in the jar to prevent molding of the food products                 
         (page 1, lines 1-8 and 78-86).                                           
              The appellants argue that Beery’s screw cap is made of              
         metal and that the piece that extends downwardly in the center           

                                        2                                         


Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007