Ex Parte Tsuchida et al - Page 5



         Appeal No. 2006-2070                                                       
         Application No. 09/986,586                                                 
              equal to the threshold value, the player parameter is                 
              changed by a first value (Column 15, lines 51-55).  When the          
              amount of damage is at least equal to the threshold value             
              and the enemy is defeated, the player parameter is changed            
              by a second value (Column 15, lines 55-59).                           
              The portion of Ohnuma relied upon by the examiner is as               
         follows:                                                                   
                   If it is determined that the value of the main                   
              character’s hit points is not “0”, the control goes to                
              Step S27 for determining whether the value of the monster’s           
              hit points is “0” or not for each of the monsters 202.  If            
              it is determined that the value of the monster’s hit points           
              is not “0” for any of the monsters 202, the control goes              
              back to Step S3 and the subsequent steps for performing the           
              next attack turn for the main character 200 or the monsters           
              202.  If it is determined that the value of monster’s hit             
              points is “0” for every monster 202, the control goes to              
              Step S28.  In Step S28, the process of gaining items, gold            
              and experiences by the main character 200 is performed.               
              Then, process of the parameter changing means 300 is brought          
              to an end.  [Col. 15, lines 48-60].                                   
         This portion discloses that if the main character and at least             
         one monster have hit points, the next attack takes place, whereas          
         if the main character, but no monster, has hit points, then the            
         main character receives items such as gold and experience points.          
         Thus, even if, as argued by the examiner, each monster’s                   
         threshold value is zero hit points, there is no disclosure of              
         relating whether a parameter assigned to the main character is             
         changed according to a first or second condition to a                      
         determination of whether the amount of damage inflicted on a               
         monster is at least that threshold value.                                  
                                         5                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007