Ex Parte Voleti et al - Page 5




         Appeal No. 2006-2336                                                       
         Application No. 09/849,916                                                 

         used to calculate the field values for each data                           
         packet in a selected frame.  Particularly, at page 11 of the               
         Appeal Brief, Appellants state:                                            
                        There is no identification of function                      
                   code formats of a selected frame as claimed,                     
                   nor use of text file to identify them. . . .                     
                                                                                   
                        No calculation of values for fields is                      
                   mentioned or implied.                                            


              To determine whether claim 1 is anticipated, we must first            
         determine the scope of the claims.  We note that claim 1 reads in          
         part as follows:                                                           
                   [U]sing a text file to identify function code                    
                   formats; and calculating values for fields                       
                   based on the function code formats.                              


         At page 6, lines 10 through 23, Appellants’ specification states:          
                        [0026] To automate the analysis of the                      
                   data patterns, a tool that functions in                          
                   accordance with the flowchart of Figure 2 is                     
                   provided.  A text file is used while                             
                   automating this analysis.  The text file                         
                   contains the data, which has details about                       
                   the data packets that are moving on the                          
                   control bus.  Values for fields such as                          
                   Enthalpy, dry bulb configuration etc., are                       
                   determined.  When the application starts, the                    
                   application reads the text file and stores                       
                   the data in a data structure.  Whenever the                      
                   user selects a data packet for analysis, the                     
                   application gets the necessary information                       
                   from the data packet and looks for a matching                    
                   record in the data structure.  Once a match                      

                                         5                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007