Ex Parte Yoakum - Page 8




           Appeal No. 2006-2574                                                                
           Application No. 10/331,706                                                          

                Again, we view it as reasonable to find that these defined                     
           skill sets must be registered vis a vis the individual resources,                   
           or agents, somewhere in the system if an agent having the                           
           particular skills called for is to be assigned to a particular                      
           task.  Otherwise, how would the management system know which                        
           agents, or resources, had the particular skills sought?                             
                Moreover, while appellant strongly asserts that we must                        
           interpret the term “registered” as it is used in the                                
           specification, or as someone skilled in the art would reasonably                    
           interpret the term, yet appellant never identifies a particular                     
           portion of the specification wherein this term is defined, and                      
           appellant does not identify what specific meaning is to be given                    
           this term that is any different from the broad, yet reasonable,                     
           interpretation of the examiner.  Exactly what interpretation,                       
           consistent with the instant specification, does appellant wish us                   
           to give the term “register”?  Appellant has not specifically                        
           said.                                                                               
                Appellant does argue that “register” should not be confused                    
           with “programming,” citing dictionary definitions at page 8 of                      
           the principal brief, but the examiner has never asserted that                       
           Kishinsky’s programming is equivalent to a “registration” and it                    
           is unclear as to exactly which definition of “register” appellant                   




                                              8                                                





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007