Ex Parte Matonog et al - Page 4



            Appeal No. 2006-1955                                                                              
            Application No. 10/818,060                                                                        

            Aldrich’s base pan is provided with a variety of air inlets and outlets, including                
            openings 80, 82, 84, 86, 88, 90, 92 in rear flange 42, openings 94, 96, 98, 100, 102              
            in starboard side flange 44, upper and lower openings 104, 106 and 108, 110 in                    
            rear wall 34 and the rear half of starboard side wall 36, openings 112, 114, 116,                 
            118, 120 in the rear half of the port side porch flange 46 and slots 126, 128, 129 in             
            the bottom wall 30 (col. 4, first para.), all of which are located so as to be                    
            essentially hidden from view and shielded to some degree from inclement weather                   
            invasion.  The bottom wall 30 of the base pan 28 has a centrally located,                         
            downwardly depressed, rectangularly shaped portion 76 (col. 3, ll. 57-59).                        
            Aldrich’s air conditioner 20 is designed to be installed on the roof of a recreational            
            vehicle, normally over an existing roof vent which is removed to create a standard                
            14 inch by 14 inch opening through the roof.  The air conditioner 20 is mounted on                
            a relatively flat level section of the roof.  A rubber gasket is attached to the bottom           
            wall 30 of the base pan 28 and adapted to register with and surround the roof                     
            opening.  Two additional gasket or cushion strips extend transversely of the air                  
            conditioner 20 between the vehicle roof and the bottom wall 30, one fore and one                  
            aft of the depression 76 to further support the air conditioner 20 with bottom wall               
            30 spaced slightly above the vehicle roof surface.   Condenser compartment outlets                
            126, 128, 129 (col. 4, ll. 24-26 and Figs. 2 and 4) communicate with this clearance               
            space.  Col. 6, last paragraph.  Aldrich thus lacks a frame on a vehicle refrigeration            
            compartment having an opening of about the size of the casing (cabinet) of the air                
            conditioner to receive the casing, as called for in appellants’ claim 1.                          

                                                      4                                                       



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013