Ex Parte Harrington et al - Page 2

               Appeal 2006-2722                                                                            
               Application 10/209,626                                                                      
                      Appellants’ invention relates to a system for fitness evaluation to be               
               used with a directly calculated or iterative optimization method for                        
               automatic document assembly.                                                                
                      Claim 1, the only claim on appeal, reads as follows:                                 
                      1.    A system for evaluating, by generating a fitness measure value,                
                      a set of variable data documents generated by an automatic document                  
                      assembly process, a set of variable data documents being a set of                    
                      documents having a portion corresponding to a predetermined content                  
                      and a portion corresponding to a variable content, the predetermined                 
                      content being the same in each document of the set of variable data                  
                      documents, comprising:                                                               
                            an input device to input document specifications for a set  of                 
                      variable data documents to be generated, the document specifications                 
                      being represented as a set of relative weights;                                      
                            a processor to generate a set of variable data documents;                      
                            said processor executing, for each variable data document, a set               
                      of value-property functions to generate a set of value properties, said              
                      set of value-property functions evaluating properties representing a                 
                      good design;                                                                         
                            said processing determining an inferred intent vector for each                 
                      variable data document as a function of the set of calculated set of                 
                      value properties, said inferred intent vector is determined by a matrix              
                      multiplication applied to a vector of value properties; and                          
                            said processor generating a fitness measure value by                           
                      multiplying components of the inferred intent vector by a                            
                      corresponding relative weight from the set of relative weights to                    
                      generate a set of products and summing the set of products.                          
                      The Examiner relies on the following prior art references to show                    
               unpatentabity:                                                                              
               Simon                   US 2002/0040375 A1              Apr. 4, 2002                       
               Kim Marriott, Bernd Meyer, and Laurent Tardif (Marriot), Fast and Efficient                 
               Client-Side Adaptivity for SVG, International World Wide Web Conference                     
               Proceedings of the Eleventh International Conference on World Wide Web,                     
               Honolulu, Hawaii, 496-507 (May 2002).                                                       

                                                    2                                                      

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013