Ex Parte Colson - Page 3


                Appeal 2006-3364                                                                                  
                Application 10/305,972                                                                            

                                         THE APPLIED PRIOR ART                                                    
                Fairbanks                               US 4,582,109                              Apr. 15, 1986   
                Alcocer                                  US 5,184,659                              Feb.  09, 1993 
                Appellant’s prior art figures 1-4                                                                 

                                              THE REJECTIONS                                                      
                       The claims stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103 as follows: claims 1-                      
                17 and 21 over the Appellant’s prior art figures 1-4 in view of Alcocer, and                      
                claims 18-20 over Fairbanks in view of Alcocer.                                                   

                                                   OPINION                                                        
                       We affirm the aforementioned rejections.                                                   

                                    Rejection over the Appellant’s prior art                                      
                                         figures 1-4 in view of Alcocer                                           
                       The Appellant’s prior art figures 1 and 2 show pleated blinds (10)                         
                having spacer cords or straps (22) attached to a headrail (14), a midrail (20)                    
                and a footrail (16) (Spec. 1: 22 – 2:10).  The Appellant’s prior art figures 3                    
                and 4 show roman shades (30) having spacer cords (44) attached to a                               
                headrail (36), a footrail (38) and, between sections of fabric shade                              
                material (32), a plurality of vertically spaced ribs (34) (Spec. 2:26 – 3:5).                     
                The attachment of the spacer cords to the ribs is by way of staples (46)                          
                (Spec. 3:2-3).                                                                                    




                                                        3                                                         

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013