Ex Parte McCarrick - Page 2

                 Appeal No. 2007-0172                                                                                    
                 Application No. 10/461,361                                                                              

                 flavor [being] different from the first flavor.”  (Specification 2-3.)  In                              
                 addition, the specification states that the cake preferably “further comprises                          
                 at least one filling portion that has a third flavor that is also different from                        
                 the first and second flavors.”  (Id. at 3.)  The specification also describes                           
                 various combinations of flavors that may be included in the cake.  (Id. at                              
                 3-4.)                                                                                                   
                                                    DISCUSSION                                                           
                 1.  CLAIMS                                                                                              
                        Claims 1 and 3-20 are pending and on appeal.  The claims have been                               
                 argued in several groups.  We will focus on one claim from each group –                                 
                 claims 1, 3, 4, 7, 11, and 15, which are representative.  Claims 19 and 20                              
                 stand or fall with claim 1.  Claims 5 and 6 stand or fall with claim 4.  Claims                         
                 8-10 stand or fall with claim 7.  Claims 12-14 stand or fall with claim 11.                             
                 Claims 16-18 stand or fall with claim 15.  37 C.F.R. § 41.37(c)(i)(vii).                                
                        Claims 1, 3, 4, 7, 11, and 15 read as follows:                                                   
                        1. A multi-flavored dessert cake comprising a plurality of                                       
                        sponge  cake  portions,  each sponge  cake  portion  capable  of                                 
                        absorbing a flavored syrup, wherein at least one sponge cake                                     
                        portion is soaked with a syrup having a first flavor and at least                                
                        one other sponge cake portion is soaked with a syrup having a                                    
                        second flavor, the second flavor being different from the first                                  
                        flavor; the cake further comprising at least one filling portion                                 
                        having a third flavor that is different from the first and second                                
                        flavors;  and  wherein  the  first,  second,  and  third  flavors                                
                        comprise one of the following flavor combinations:                                               
                                i) a first flavor combination in which one of the first,                                 
                        second,  and  third  flavors  comprises  a  lemongrass  flavor,                                  
                        another  of  the  first,  second, and  third  flavors  comprises  a                              
                        mango flavor, and another of the first, second, and third flavors                                
                        comprises a caramel flavor;                                                                      

                                                           2                                                             

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013