Ex Parte Vincent - Page 7

                Appeal 2007-0271                                                                              
                Application 09/750,948                                                                        

                      3.  Net Perceptions discloses “generat[ing] a set of rules based upon                   
                said patterns” in that such rules would be required for the recommendation                    
                engine to “prompt[] agents with pertinent customer information and specific                   
                purchase recommendations for whoever is on the line”.  (Id.  See also                         
                Answer 9.)                                                                                    
                      4.  One of ordinary skill in the art would equate “a rules engine”                      
                (Spec. 1), with a “recommendation engine” (claim 11).  (See also Net                          
                Perceptions, ¶ 4; Andrew passim.)                                                             
                      5.  Finally, Net Perceptions discloses “using a recommendation engine                   
                to apply said rules to a current customer interaction to recognize one or more                
                of said patterns in said interaction and suggest an interaction strategy                      
                corresponding to said recognized patterns.”  (See Net Perceptions, ¶¶ 2-4                     
                (“system’s recommendation engine zeroes in on individual preferences by                       
                pooling information from current customers and previous calls, and by                         
                drawing upon a database of information on other customers with similar                        
                buying patterns” and “prompts agents with pertinent customer information                      
                and specific purchase recommendations” based on the identified patterns).)                    
                      6.  Andrews further describes Net Perceptions’ recommendation                           
                engines and their versatility and identifies Net Perceptions as one company                   
                offering recommendation engines.  (See Andrews passim.)                                       
                      7.  Andrews discloses, or at least suggests, using “executable                          
                instructions for analyzing customer data from [a] plurality of channels.”                     
                (Andrews, ¶ 1 (“recommendation engines,” such as that of Net Perceptions,                     
                “can use multiple channels”).  See also Andrews, ¶ 4 (“Net Perceptions’                       
                recommendation engine . . . provide[s] advice to consumers . . . through                      


                                                      7                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013