Ex Parte Noda et al - Page 5

                Appeal 2007-0756                                                                                
                Application 10/652,853                                                                          
                       taken.  The Examiner does not assert that the dashed-line squares are                    
                       both the pumps and the suction ports of the pump.  Rather, we                            
                       understand the Examiner’s position to be that the suction ports are                      
                       disposed someplace along the periphery of the dashed-line squares, as                    
                       this is the place where the hydraulic fluid enters the pumps, which are                  
                       represented by the dashed-line squares.                                                  
                   3. Nohira’s valves SI1 and SI2, identified by the Examiner without                           
                       challenge from Appellants as the suction valves, are illustrated in Fig.                 
                       9 closer to the peripheries of the dashed-line squares representing the                  
                       pumps than the valves SC1 and SC2, identified by the Examiner                            
                       without challenge from Appellants as the regulators.  Moreover, the                      
                       valves PC1 through PC8, identified by the Examiner without                               
                       challenge from Appellants as control valve units, are further from the                   
                       suction ports of the pumps than are the regulators SC1 and SC2.                          
                   4. Nohira’s Fig. 3 is a perspective view of the hydraulic pressure unit                      
                       shown in plan view in Fig. 1 and in schematic block diagram form in                      
                       Fig. 4.  The spatial relationships illustrated in Fig. 1 are consistent                  
                       with those indicated in the perspective view of Fig. 3.  Figs. 7 and 8                   
                       are a schematic block diagram and plan view, respectively, of a                          
                       conventional system with a traction control system (Nohira, col. 1, ll.                  
                       30-31 and 43-50).  Nohira’s Fig. 9 is a plan view of a hydraulic                         
                       pressure control system of the type illustrated in Figs. 7 and 8 that                    
                       additionally performs a steering control by braking operation.  Such a                   
                       system requires control of the brake fluid at relatively high pressure                   
                       and therefore utilizes electromagnetic valves SC1, SC2, SI1, and SI2                     
                       having solenoid coil portions of relatively large outer diameters.                       

                                                       5                                                        

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013