Ex Parte Hanyu et al - Page 2

               Appeal 2007-1001                                                                       
               Application 10/602,197                                                                 
                    (a)  providing a first crystalline thermoplastic polymer;                         
                    (b)  extruding the first crystalline thermoplastic polymer and forming            
               the first crystalline thermoplastic polymer into a flexible substrate layer            
               having an interface surface;                                                           
                    (c)  providing a second polymer comprising a polymer consisting                   
               essentially of a syndiotactic propylene polymer having a melt flow index of            
               less than 2 grams/10 minutes produced by the polymerization of propylene               
               in the presence of a syndiospecific metallocene catalyst effective to form a           
               surface layer, the surface layer capable of producing a heat seal with itself at       
               a seal temperature less than 110ēC;                                                    
                    (d)  extruding the syndiotactic propylene polymer to form a surface               
               layer; and                                                                             
                    (e)  bonding the surface layer to the interface surface of the substrate          
               layer to form a multilayer film having a surface of syndiotactic propylene             
               polymer which has a thickness that is less than the thickness of the substrate         
               layer.                                                                                 
                    The Examiner relies upon the following references as evidence of                  
               obviousness:                                                                           
               Bothe    US 5,254,394  Oct. 19, 1993                                                   
               Peet    US 6,387,529 B1  May 14, 2002                                                  
                    Appellants' claimed invention is directed to a process for producing a            
               multilayer film having a substrate layer and a surface layer wherein the               
               surface layer comprises a polymer consisting essentially of a syndiotactic             
               propylene polymer having a melt flow index of less than 2 grams/10                     
               minutes.                                                                               
                    Appealed claims 21-26 stand rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 103(a) as                  
               being unpatentable over Bothe in view of Peet.                                         



                                                  2                                                   

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013