Ex Parte Lindsey et al - Page 3

                 Appeal 2007-1199                                                                                                       
                 Application 10/124,648                                                                                                 
                 only four locations, and with a ratio of haptic spread to optic diameter of less                                       
                 than 1.5, and preferably around 1.3 for a 5.5 mm optic provides sufficient                                             
                 stability without excessive angle contact.  (Specification 5: 17-21).                                                  
                        5. Further still according to the Applicants, they have recognized                                              
                 that the compressive force of haptics and footplates on haptics need to be                                             
                 sufficient for the stability of the optical lens but not large enough to cause                                         
                 irritation or pupil ovaling.  (Specification 6: 4-6).                                                                  
                        6. Claims 1 and 10 are the only independent claims on appeal.                                                   
                 They read as follows:                                                                                                  
                              1.     An intraocular lens, comprising:                                                                   
                                     a)   an optic having a diameter; and                                                               
                                     b)   at least one pair of footplates, the footplates                                               
                        being separated by a haptic and attached to the optic by a ramp,                                                
                        the ramp being wider in a plane in which the optic lays than it is                                              
                        in a plane perpendicular to the plane of the optic,                                                             
                              wherein the intraocular lens exhibits a force response of                                                 
                        approximately less than 0.5 mN when the intraocular lens is                                                     
                        compressed 1 mm.                                                                                                
                              10.    An intraocular lens, comprising:                                                                   
                                     a)   an optic having a diameter; and                                                               
                                     b)   a pair of footplates, each of the footplates                                                  
                        being separated by a haptic and attached to the optic by a ramp,                                                
                        the ramp being wider in a plane in which the optic lays than it is                                              
                        in a plane perpendicular to the plane of the optic, the optic,                                                  
                        footplates and ramps being made in a single piece entirely from                                                 
                        a soft acrylic,                                                                                                 
                              wherein the intraocular lens exhibits a force response of                                                 
                        approximately less than 0.5 mN when the intraocular lens is                                                     
                        compressed 1 mm.                                                                                                
                        7. Citing Figures 10-12 of Nigam, the Examiner determined that                                                  
                 Nigam discloses an intraocular lens comprising an optic (22) having a                                                  



                                                         3                                                                              








Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013