Ex Parte Cable et al - Page 3

                  Appeal 2007-1214                                                                                            
                  Application 10/272,270                                                                                      

                  exciter without the need for additional support springs” (id. at 14).  The                                  
                  ovoid coil spring also “has a consistent, repeatable spring rate, [and] an                                  
                  effectively infinite shelf life” and can be manufactured to close tolerances                                
                  more easily than elastomer springs (id.).  The Specification discloses that                                 
                  “[a]lthough ovoid-shaped springs are somewhat easier to manufacture,                                        
                  springs closer to true rectangles can also be used” in vibratory feeders (id. at                            
                  10).                                                                                                        
                                                      DISCUSSION                                                              
                  1.  CLAIMS                                                                                                  
                         Claims 1-13 are on appeal.  Claim 14 is also pending but has been                                    
                  withdrawn from consideration by the Examiner.                                                               
                         Claim 1 is representative and reads as follows:                                                      
                                 1.  A vibratory conveying apparatus, comprising:                                             
                                        a trough having a conveying surface;                                                  
                                        a vibratory exciter;                                                                  
                                        a first coil spring arranged to be compressed                                         
                         between a first portion of the trough and a first portion of the                                     
                         exciter, said first coil spring having a longitudinal axis around                                    
                         which said first coil spring is wound, a transverse axis and a                                       
                         lateral axis, said transverse axis and said lateral axis being                                       
                         perpendicular and in a plane perpendicular to the longitudinal                                       
                         axis;                                                                                                
                                 wherein an outside dimension of said first coil spring is                                    
                         greater along the lateral axis than along the transverse axis; and                                   
                                 wherein the lateral axis of the first coil spring is generally                               
                         parallel to a vertical plane containing the longitudinal axis.                                       
                         Thus, claim 1 is directed to a vibratory conveyor that has a trough, a                               
                  vibratory exciter, and a coil spring compressed between the trough and                                      
                  exciter.  As we interpret the claim language, the dimensions specified for the                              


                                                              3                                                               

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013