Ex Parte Molenaar - Page 6



            Appeal 2007-1792                                                                                 
            Application 10/050,834                                                                           
                      the use of a seal for preventing foreign matter from working its way past              
                      the seal into the ball joint and includes a plurality of grooves which                 
                      provide a passage for the extrusion of lubricant when additional grease is             
                      added via the lubricating port.  Adding additional grease causes any dirt              
                      that has managed to enter the ball joint to be extruded via the grooves                
                      before it can cause any harm to the surfaces of the ball or seat (Edwards,             
                      col. 3, ll. 10-41).  Figure 2 shows that the grooves provide a path for                
                      grease from the lubricating port to the face of the ball (Edwards, Fig. 2).            
                      Edwards further teaches an externally threaded connecting rod that                     
                      extends from a housing containing a ball joint transversely of a vehicle               
                      (Edwards, col.1, l. 45 – col. 2, l. 5, Fig. 1).                                        
                   3. McEowen teaches including lubrication grooves in the spherical bearing                 
                      surface of the ball in a ball joint which form grease reservoirs in the                
                      bearing surface without introducing aberrations in the finished bearing                
                      surface (McEowen, col. 1, ll. 57-61, Fig. 9).  McEowen further discloses               
                      grease grooves located in the internally conformed lower end of the                    
                      housing (shown as the upper end because the Figures of McEowen are                     
                      upside down relative to those of the Appellant’s application)  (McEowen,               
                      col. 3, l. 37 – col. 4, l. 2).                                                         
                   4. As shown in Figure 9, Scheublein, Jr. discloses a ball joint which may be              
                      used for the lower arm of a suspension system comprising an elongated                  
                      shaft 94, a ball 100, a retaining member 127, and a housing (118, 119,                 
                      and 120).  The shaft has an upper end (nearest the ball), a lower end                  

                                                     6                                                       



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013