Ex Parte SMITH - Page 10



            Appeal 2007-1925                                                                                
            Application 09/391,869                                                                          

            Findings of Fact Relating to Obviousness                                                        
                   7. Wyant discloses at least one pocket formed between a card and a tab                   
                         yielding panel (Wyant, col. 3, ll. 28-29).                                         
                   8. Wyant teaches that the card may be of any convenient size or shape                    
                         (Wyant, col. 2, ll. 16-20).                                                        
                   9. Wyant also discloses that the indexing member may be formed from                      
                         any conventional stationary paper including card stock and paper                   
                         stock (Wyant, col. 2, ll. 21-25).                                                  
                   10. Wyant teaches that the tab yielding panel can be folded inwardly to                  
                         secure the panel to the card with an adhesive along the inside margins             
                         of the tab yielding panel, which results in two-ply seams (Wyant,                  
                         col. 2, ll. 49-53).                                                                
                   11. In an alternate embodiment, Wyant teaches securing the tab yielding                  
                         panel to the card by top and bottom marginal panels which overlap the              
                         tab yielding panel, resulting in three plies along its top and bottom              
                         edges (Wyant, col. 2, ll. 53-61).                                                  
                   12. The pocket is shown and described as facing toward the apertures                     
                         used to retain the card in a three ring binder (Wyant, col. 2, ll. 53-55,          
                         col. 3, ll. 9-13, Figure 1).                                                       
                   13. Any convenient bonding method including adhesive can be used to                      
                         secure the tab yielding panel to the card (Wyant, col. 2, ll. 50-53).              
                   14. Dick discloses that it has been a common practice to have portfolios in              
                         which leaves are permanently attached to a binder element of the book              
                                                    10                                                      



Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013