Ex Parte Wilson - Page 4

                Appeal 2007-2774                                                                              
                Application 10/285,632                                                                        
                II. Findings of Fact (FF)                                                                     
                      The following findings of fact are supported by a preponderance of                      
                the evidence of record.                                                                       
                      1. Appellant's Specification                                                            
                 [1] According to Appellant's Specification, automotive assembly paint                        
                      shops use flush solutions to remove residual paint from paint                           
                      application equipment in various cleaning cycles, e.g., paint line purge                
                      and nozzle or cap wash cycles (Specification at 1).                                     
                 [2] Appellant's Specification describes a process for removing paint                         
                      particles from a "dirty" flush solution comprising "providing dirty                     
                      flush solution; directing the dirty flush solution to a treatment vessel;               
                      adding one or more chemicals to the treatment vessel to form a treated                  
                      flush solution; separating aggregated paint compounds from the                          
                      treated flush solution to form a filtered flush solution; and directing                 
                      the filtered flush solution to spray application equipment"                             
                      (Specification at 2).                                                                   
                 [3] The chemicals used to treat the dirty flush solution are coagulants                      
                      and/or flocculants that cause the paint particles to aggregate and are                  
                      commonly used in the automotive industry for treating wastewater                        
                      (Specification at 4-5).                                                                 
                 [4] Exemplary coagulants include di- or tri-valent metal salts and water-                    
                      soluble electrolytes; exemplary flocculants include cationic and                        
                      anionic polymers (Specification at 5).                                                  
                 [5] The amount of coagulant/flocculant added to the treatment vessel                         
                      depends upon the concentration of paint in the dirty flush solution,                    



                                                      4                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013