Ex Parte Scioscio - Page 7

                Appeal 2007-2893                                                                             
                Application 10/818,885                                                                       

                      For clarity, we reproduce Proctor’s figure 1 below:                                    













                Accordingly, with reference to Proctor’s figure 1, we find that Proctor                      
                teaches a cooking container for transferring heat from a heat source (e.g., an               
                open flame or burner) to food contents therein which comprises:                              
                      1.  an inner wall (16, e.g., a shell) having a top opening and a first                 
                heat-conductive plate bottom (e.g., 30) to distribute applied heat to food                   
                contents within the shell;                                                                   
                      2. a second heat-conductive plate (e.g., 28) that extends downwardly                   
                from the first plate, is adapted for placement directly on a heat source (e.g.,              
                an open flame or burner), and forms a sealed cavity (40) of predetermined                    
                volume between the first and second heat-conductive plates; and                              
                      3. an art recognized heat-transfer liquid that does not completely fill                
                the sealed cavity (40).                                                                      
                      Proctor differs from claim 1 in two regards.  First, Proctor does not                  
                specifically teach that silicon oil is an art recognized heat-transfer liquid.               


                                                     7                                                       

Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next

Last modified: September 9, 2013