Estate of Gordon H. Bartels, Deceased, Sally A. Jouris and Thomas G. Bartels, Executors, and Estate of Violet J. Bartels, Deceased, Sally A. Jouris and Thomas G. Bartels, Executors - Page 9

                                        - 9 -                                         


          the committee reports accompanying the 1932 Act.  No comparable             
          section was included in the estate tax provisions of the 1932               
          Act.                                                                        
               Sections 274(g) and 512(g) were incorporated into the                  
          Internal Revenue Code of 1939 by section 272(g) (relating to the            
          income tax) and section 1012(g) (relating to the gift tax); again           
          no comparable section was included in the estate tax provisions             
          of the 1939 Code.  This situation remained until the enactment of           
          the 1954 Code when sections 272(g) and 1012(g) were combined into           
          section 6214(b).  The only legislative history in respect of this           
          action is the identical comment in the committee reports that               
          "This section represents no change in existing law".  H. Rept.              
          1337, 83d Cong., 2d Sess. A405 (1954); S. Rept. 1622, 83d Cong.,            
          2d Sess. 573 (1954).  Of interest is the fact that section                  
          6214(b) speaks only of an income tax or gift tax deficiency                 
          although it is included in subchapter B of chapter 63 entitled              
          "Deficiency Procedures in the Case of Income, Estate, Gift * * *            
          Taxes".                                                                     
               Granted that there is no legislative explanation as to why             
          the limitation of the authority of this Court by section 6214(b)            
          or its antecedents did not extend to the estate tax, the                    
          foregoing analysis of legislative action reinforces our                     
          interpretation that the words "the tax" in section 6214(b) are              
          limited to income and gift taxes and therefore do not preclude us           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011