Texasgulf Inc. and Subsidiaries, as Successor in Interest to Texasgulf Inc. and Subsidiaries - Page 24

                                       - 24 -                                         

          Parsons OMT Report.  Parsons analyzed returns as filed; i.e.,               
          before assessment by the Mine Assessor.  Later, Parsons obtained            
          records of the Mine Assessor’s adjustments to the filed returns.            
          He included assessment data in his rebuttal memorandum to the               
          extent it was available.  The parties stipulated that the data              
          (but not the opinions and conclusions) in the Parsons OMT Report            
          was accurate.                                                               
               Of the 213 returns that Parsons reviewed, 145 returns (68.1            
          percent) reported OMT liability.  Nonrecoverable expenses exceed            
          the processing allowance on only 19 of the OMT returns which                
          reported OMT liability (15.8 percent).                                      
               The Parsons OMT Report shows that, in the aggregate,                   
          processing allowances claimed by OMT taxpayers dwarfed                      
          nonrecoverable expenses:                                                    
                                  Millions of Can$                                    

                              Nonrecoverable   Processing                             
                         Year      Expenses       Allowance                           
                         1968      10.6           91.6                                
                         1969      9.7            76.3                                
                         1970      30.2           99.7                                
                         1971      39.6           36.9                                
                         1972      51.7           92.6                                
                         1973      54.1           140.6                               
                         1974      57.6           196.8                               
                         1975      61.6           252.2                               
                         1976      70.0           217.8                               
                         1977      73.3           43.2                                
                         1978      83.4           94.7                                
                         1979      64.1           321.8                               
                         1980      99.3           573.5                               
                         Total   705.2            2,237.7                             
                         Average   54.3           172.1                               




Page:  Previous  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011