Benjamin H. and Diane E. Robson - Page 7

                                        - 7 -                                         
          gating violations of Federal and State wildlife laws.  Through              
          undercover work involved in his position with the Fish and                  
          Wildlife Service, Mr. Curry has personally purchased and sold               
          game mounts, and he has been involved with the investigation of             
          other sales of wildlife.  Mr. Curry asserted that, despite his              
          department's efforts, an illegal market in game mounts existed in           
          California during the years at issue.                                       
               Mr. Curry submitted a report in which he summarized the                
          price range at which various game mounts were sold in California.           
          Mr. Curry's report contained price ranges for those animal                  
          specimens with which he had gained familiarity through the                  
          performance of his duties as an agent.  His price ranges in most            
          cases were in line with the amounts contained in Mr. Zanotti's              
          report.                                                                     
               Petitioners rely exclusively on the testimony of Mr. Perry.            
          Mr. Perry is on the board of the World Wildlife Museum,1 and he             
          has substantial experience in the field of taxidermy.                       
               Mr. Perry bases his appraisals on the replacement cost                 
          methodology.  Replacement cost is the total cost the hunter                 
          incurred in going on the hunt and related costs such as trophy              
          fees, taxidermy costs, and travel expenses.  If more than one               


               1Mr. Perry admitted that he was motivated to perform                   
          appraisals by factors other than the fees he charged.  In fact,             
          he candidly stated that his "ulterior motive" in performing                 
          appraisals was to encourage the donation of animal specimens to             
          museums.                                                                    




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011