Preston L. and Ruby M. Payton - Page 6

                                        - 6 -                                         

          apartment "shall be used solely for private residential                     
          purposes."  There is no evidence that Ruby was a party to any of            
          the three leases or that she received any exception from the                
          lessor to use the apartment for her business purposes.                      
               We also observe that the addresses listed on Preston's and             
          Ruby's 1994 Forms W-2 are different.  No Forms W-2 for 1993 for             
          either Preston or Ruby were in the record.  Ruby explained that             
          the address Preston used was a post office box and that it was              
          not Preston's residence.  However, Ruby admitted that the post              
          office box is located near the apartment that Preston rented.  We           
          believe that Preston rented the apartment for his own personal              
          purposes and not for Ruby's beauty sales business.  Any purported           
          use of the apartment by Ruby is not supported by the evidence in            
          the record.  Thus, we conclude that petitioners are not entitled            
          to deduct rental payments in the amount of $8,028 for each of the           
          years 1993 and 1994.                                                        
               At trial, Ruby raised for the first time another new issue             
          with respect to whether petitioners should be allowed to deduct             
          the amounts of $4,140 and $4,460 for 1993 and 1994, respectively,           
          for "other expenses" for casual labor incurred on behalf of                 
          Ruby's rooming house.  Again, as to this second new issue,                  
          petitioners did not claim any such expenses for casual labor as             
          deductions with respect to the rooming house on the Schedules C             
          for either year at issue.                                                   





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011