Estate of Honore V. De St. Aubin, Deceased, Ovide E. De St. Aubin, Executor, et al. - Page 28

                                       - 28 -                                         

             statute under any circumstances.  We note that reallocation              
             of proceeds under EPTL section 11-2.1(k) is triggered by                 
             failure to meet an objective standard of productivity.                   
             The statute does not require or allow different treatment                
             as a result of the cause a failure to meet that level of                 
             productivity.                                                            
                  Application of the 1987 provision results in no                     
             reallocation of proceeds.  EPTL section 11-2.1(k)(1), as                 
             amended in 1987, provides as follows:                                    
                                                                                     
                       Except as otherwise provided in this                           
                  paragraph (k), a portion of the net proceeds of                     
                  a sale by a fiduciary  * * * of any principal                       
                  property of an estate or trust * * * held for                       
                  more than a year which has not produced over the                    
                  period held an average net income of one percent                    
                  per annum of its inventory value (including as                      
                  income the value of any beneficial use of the                       
                  property by any income beneficiary), shall be                       
                  allocated to income as delayed income, as                           
                  provided in this paragraph (k).  * * *                              

                  EPTL section 11-2.1(o)(4) defines "inventory value",                
             for purposes of section 11-2.1, as "the cost of property                 
             purchased by the trustee and the market value of other                   
             property at the time it was made subject to the trust."                  
             The parties dispute the meaning of the phrase "made subject              
             to the trust".  Petitioners assert that EPTL section                     
             11-2.1(c)(1) provides that Mr. de St. Aubin's assets were                
             "made subject to the trust" as of his date of death.                     





Page:  Previous  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  34  35  36  37  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011