Estate of Fred O. Godley, Deceased, Fred D. Godley, Administrator CTA - Page 11




                                        - 11 -                                          
               In a report prepared for this Court in valuing decedent’s                
          interests, Beck concluded that a lack of marketability discount               
          of 25 percent and a lack of control discount of 15 percent should             
          apply to the values derived in his valuation of Fred Jr.’s                    
          interests in the housing partnerships, which would result4 in                 
          values as follows:                                                            
                    Partnership                      Value                              
                    Monroe                         $149,591                             
                    Clinton                        50,487                               
                    Rocky Mount                    59,697                               
                    Charlotte                      63,114                               
               In addition to the partnerships in issue, at the time of his             
          death, decedent and Fred Jr. each owned 50 percent of the stock               
          of Godley Realty, Inc. (Godley Realty), and decedent owned a 25-              
          percent interest and Fred Jr. owned a 75-percent interest in                  
          Concrete Panel Systems, Inc., of North Carolina (CPSI).  In the               
          notice of deficiency, respondent determined that the value of                 
          decedent’s interest in Godley Realty was $225,048 as of the                   
          valuation date and the value of decedent’s interest in CPSI was               
          $34,271 as of the valuation date.5  Respondent’s valuations of                
          Godley Realty and CPSI were based, in part, upon the November 11,             
          1990, balance sheets, which reflect accounts payable to the five              


               4  In his trial testimony, Beck clarified that the                       
          compounding of these two discounts would produce a total discount             
          of 36.25 percent.                                                             
               5  The parties have stipulated that these values are                     
          correct.                                                                      




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011